IRA-pension rescue, Pt.2 -- The "new" pension rescue
By Roccy Defrancesco
The Wealth Preservation Institute
In part one of this series, I explained the 75 percent tax trap that millions of people have with money in their IRAs and/or qualified plans. Additionally, I explained one simple solution called liquidate and leverage (L&L), which will pass significantly more money to heirs at the time of a client's death than doing nothing.
The "new" pension rescue
In part two, I will discuss the "new" version of "old school" pension rescue. In order to understand this material, you first need to understand old school pension rescue.
What is pension rescue?
Pension rescue is when a client buys a 5-pay life insurance policy inside a qualified retirement plan to soak up the majority of the money in the plan, where after purchase, the policy is sold to an ILIT at a discount, thereby saving the client on both income and estate taxes due on the money at death and where a large death benefit is purchased using a life insurance policy owned by an ILIT.
The IRS killed old school pension rescue
As many advisors know, the IRS killed "old school" pension rescue with Rev. Proc. 2004-16; and Rev. Ruling 2004-20 and 2004-21. Why did these kill pension rescue? Because the new value of a cash-value life insurance policy for roll out or purchase by an ILIT would be nearly the same amount as the premiums paid, and therefore, there is virtually no tax savings to the transaction.
As is the case many times with the IRS's guidance, it made little sense to those in the industry. Having said that, the IRS accomplished its goal of throwing cold water on that pension rescue technique, and most in the industry stopped using it back in 2004 (2004-21 put it on the listed tax transaction list, which really helped advisors stay away from it).
Pension rescue is back with a safe harbor valuation
The first thing that helped bring pension rescue back is Rev. Proc. 2005-25. The IRS offered a new "safe harbor" that included a new average surrender factor (ASF) for the valuation of life insurance policies that were to be either distributed from or purchased from a qualified retirement plan. The ASF is basically a factor used in a formula to derive the FMV of a policy. The factor is typically between 70 percent and 100 percent, depending on the policy year.
How is the ASF applied to come up with this new safe harbor value? To make things simple, take the cash account value (CAV) of a life insurance policy upon sale or distributions from a qualified plan and multiply that by the ASF.
Let's look at an example, in case you're not following me:
If you have $1,000,000 in a qualified plan and you use pension rescue, you would pay premiums of $200,000 a year for five years to soak up the money into the policy. At the end of the fifth year, you would value the policy as it is distributed to the plan participant or sold to an ILIT.
If the CAV is $800,000 you would multiply that by the ASF, which should be approximately 70 percent in year five if you are using a properly designed policy.
$800,000 x 70 percent = $560,000
How do clients normally solve the 75 percent tax trap? They don't. Most do nothing or painfully pay premiums after tax to an ILIT to buy a large death benefit.
What were the real savings to this client?
The profit sharing plan now has $560,000 in it instead of $1,000,000. Therefore, the client avoided the 75 percent tax on $440,000 dollars, which would have been double taxed had it been left in the plan. In 2011 and beyond, this would save his heirs $242,000 or more, depending on what President Obama does with his massive tax increases.
And the client moved from the "do nothing" position most clients are stuck with and ended up being proactive to mitigate the 75 percent tax trap, while at the same time moving a life insurance policy to an ILIT, which will significantly increase the after-tax estate passed to the heirs.
What about IRAs?
If you have clients with sizable account balances in IRAs and estate tax problems, never fear, you can help them. These types of clients should have at least one family limited partnership (FLP) for asset protection and estate planning reasons. If they don't have one, you can help them create one. Once an FLP is created, the client will become an employee/manager of the FLP. Once an employee, a new profit sharing plan can be created inside the FLP and the IRA money can then be rolled into the newly created plan, where the client can then take advantage of the "new" pension rescue.
Summary of the "new" pension rescue
The 75 percent tax trap of money in a qualified plan or IRA is one of the most difficult issues to deal with in a client's estate plan. Doing nothing should not be an option for your clients, as the maximum amount of money will be paid to the IRS upon a client's death. As you read in part one, liquidate and leverage is much better than doing nothing. While L&L is simple, it is not as powerful as the "new" pension rescue technique which can now be done properly with guidance from the IRS.
If you want to move into the affluent client market, this is a terrific topic to use as a door-opener. You can be nearly guaranteed that the client's current advisors are not discussing how to mitigate the 75 percent tax trap, and once you bring this topic to the table, you'll be seen as a real problem-solver in the client's eyes. Additionally, if you make money selling insurance, you'll love this topic as the commissions are usually quite large, and are not a detriment to the transaction.
*For further information, or to contact this author, please leave a comment and your e-mail address in the forum below.