The variable high deductible health plan (V-HDHP)Article added by Robert Hopper on April 30, 2009
Robert Hopper

Robert Hopper

Joined: August 21, 2010

The variable high deductible health plan (V-HDHP)

Have insurance companies forgotten how to design pure insurance policies? What about a no-frills health insurance plan that truly is affordable? I think the market for such a policy has the potential to be enormous.

I'm frugal when it comes to buying insurance for myself. Thus far, I have a $3,500 deductible HSA-qualified health plan. I pay all medical bills up to $3,500; including annual physicals, physician office visits, labs, x-rays and prescriptions. The insurance company pays everything over $3,500. If I have a $100,000 medical bill, I pay $3,500 and the insurance company pays $96,500.

Since my plan is bare-bones insurance, the premiums are more affordable than a plan that provides co-pays for office visits and prescriptions. Compared to the lowest cost traditional PPO plan with co-pays for doctor visits and brand-name prescriptions, I save about $200 per month or $2,400 per year, and I put that savings directly into my health savings account. With good health, unused dollars roll over each year; and the account really builds up quickly.

Recently my insurance company levied a substantial premium increase. Logically, if you want to retain a low premium, you simply raise the deductible. But my insurance company does not have a higher deductible. When I called my contact in management for that company, she said they were working on some new plans, and it should be ready by 2010.

In 2005 I wrote my continuing education textbook on health savings accounts for the insurance industry (The HSA Strategy: The Future of Health Insurance in America), and I recommended that insurance companies offer a wide variety of deductibles, so that people can control premiums by raising deductibles. Here is a sample array of deductibles:
    $5,800 (2009)
The $1,500 deductible plan is just right for people with a low tolerance for risk and a willingness to pay a higher premium. HSA-qualified plans must have at least a $1,150 deductible, and $1,500 is a nice round number. Saving just $125 each month ($1500 a year) in the HSA would cover all the expenses up to the deductible. You could plan and save for the future by making additional contributions.

As HSA savings grow to $3,000+, a person might be comfortable choosing a $2,500 or $3,500 deductible plan and pay a lower premium, freeing up more money for the HSA.

Finally, when a person has $10,000+ in his or her HSA, it makes sense to buy a plan with the highest deductible and cut premiums substantially.

The variable high deductible health plan (V-HDHP)

This new plan could serve a very large pool of people who want insurance for the big bills and are willing to pay the smaller bills out of their HSAs.
  • Variable deductible: Insurance companies should offer one plan where the highest deductible equals the out-of-pocket maximum prescribed by the Treasury Department. In 2008 the out-of-pocket maximum was $5,600, and it goes up a little each year. In 2009 the limit is $5,800. Insurance companies can create a $5,800 deductible for 2009, and then raise the deductible as the out-of-pocket maximum specified by the U.S. Treasury increase.

  • Embedded deductible: Now, a $5,800 deductible is a bit scary for families, because with an HSA-qualified high deductible health plan, there is one family aggregate deductible of $11,600. I wouldn't buy that plan. But if the plan included an embedded deductible, that would work. If just one person has large medical bills, he or she only needs to meet the $5,800 deductible.

  • Exclude outpatient doctor visits: In the quest to find more affordable coverage, I really don't need insurance to pay a doctor visit fee. The average negotiated fee for a visit to a general doctor ranges from $65 to $90, and to a specialist from $85 to $150. Maybe insurance companies could exclude routine doctor visits, and in exchange, provide a lower premium.

  • Exclude routine prescriptions: And for that matter, I don't need insurance to pay for a monthly prescription drug that might cost $100 a month. If they exclude the routine prescriptions such as blood pressure, cholesterol and allergy medications, they could offer an even lower premium. Of course, I would like them to continue covering specialty drugs, such as injectable medications that cost in excess of $2,000 per month. These types of medications can be called "large and unexpected," and fall under the concept of insurance.

  • Exclude annual physicals (?): I really think the annual physical benefit is a good benefit, and including an annual physical paid 100 percent by the health plan may encourage people to have that exam regularly. Yet, my current plan doesn't cover it, and I still have a regular exams. For this one variable HDHP, let's not include the annual exam, and squeeze a little lower premium out of the insurance company.
The bottom line

I think there are a substantial number of people who say: "Give me insurance just for the large and unexpected medical bills." Eliminate coverage for routine expenses I can pay out of my pocket. As a trade-off, give me a rock-bottom premium. In other words, give me pure insurance. A $5,800 deductible plan should be the lowest cost plan on the market.

*For further information, or to contact this author, please leave a comment and your e-mail address in the forum below.
The views expressed here are those of the author and not necessarily those of ProducersWEB.
Reprinting or reposting this article without prior consent of is strictly prohibited.
If you have questions, please visit our terms and conditions
Post Article