TDFs popular, but did not perform well in 2011: Morningstar

By BenefitsPro

By Paula Aven Gladych

Morningstar’s 2012 Industry Survey examines growth in target-date funds and the fact that they incurred steep losses in 2008. In early 2012, the Securities and Exchange Commission reopened the comment period on its recommendations for improved disclosure requirements for target-date funds, which were first proposed in 2010.

According to the Morningstar report, the SEC backed up its proposals with a survey on investor understanding of target-date funds. It found that target-date providers and plan sponsors don’t do a good job of educating plan participants about these offerings.

Target-date funds have grown more than fivefold from $71 billion at the end of 2005 to about $378 billion at year-end 2011, according to the report. A recent study by Vanguard found that 82 percent of its retirement plans offered target-date funds and nearly one-fourth of participants invested only in a target-date fund. Industry experts believe that target-date funds will consume more than half of all defined contribution assets by 2020.

In its industry survey, Morningstar found that target-date assets continue to increase at a healthy rate, surpassing most broad asset classes, but a slowing rate of increase does raise some concerns. It also found that several smaller firms have had impressive gains in organic growth for their series, whether through unconventional design, strong performance or power distribution.

Index-based series’ assets increased at a faster rate than actively managed series in 2011 and glide paths to retirement changed minimally in 2011.

The 2012 report found that performance for target-date series in 2011 was weak on a relative basis. Most categories turned in losses, and every category trailed major benchmarks. Strategies that had more conservative allocations, more basic asset mixes, or indexed approaches outperformed in 2011.

Originally published on